The US is grappling with insurance challenges as homeowners nationwide struggle to find affordable coverage for wildfire protection. This issue, which has been escalating over the past four to five years, has been exacerbated by a significant reduction in offerings from admitted insurance markets in the last two to three years. Some insurers are scaling back their presence or exiting entirely in states such as California.

Recently rolled out regulations are designed to attract insurance markets back to high-risk areas in California, but their effectiveness has yet to be seen.

In a historic move, the California Fair Plan has imposed a billion-dollar assessment on its member insurers for the first time in 30 years, highlighting the urgent need for solutions to bridge the widening insurance gap. In many of the highest risk communities in California, the Fair Plan is essentially the only available market.

Excess and Surplus Insurers Maintain Moratoriums Amid Uncertainty

In the aftermath of recent wildfires, the insurance industry is facing uncertainty as many admitted as well as Excess and Surplus (E&S) insurers maintain moratoriums on new policies. These pauses are largely due to the industry's ongoing assessment of total losses. Insurers are still evaluating the impact on their portfolios, compounded by assessments from the California Fair Plan.

As the industry waits for the dust to settle, there's hope that E&S insurers will eventually lift their moratoriums and resume taking on new risks. However, any return to the market is expected to come with tighter underwriting guidelines and a more restricted appetite for risk. This return could mean stricter limits on total insured values (TIV) and a more selective approach to coverage.

Despite the challenges, there's potential for new entrants in the E&S space, leveraging advanced modeling and technology to offer more tailored solutions. These new players aim to work closely with homeowners, advising on risk mitigation strategies that could reduce wildfire risk and make coverage more attainable. While not a blanket solution, this interactive approach offers a glimmer of hope for homeowners willing to engage in proactive risk management on a case-by-case basis.

Risk Mitigation and Transparency Are Key

In California's challenging insurance market, homeowners who take proactive measures to prepare their property can have an advantage in their search for affordable insurance coverage. Once they're insured, it's crucial for policyholders to comply with any risk mitigation measures their insurer requires. With the odds stacked against securing coverage, ensuring compliance with an insurer's requirements becomes even more critical to avoid losing that hard-won protection. There have been instances where coverage was revoked after inspections revealed that homeowners didn't follow these measures.

Given the current market conditions, it's essential for brokers and homeowners to explore multiple options. Different agents may have access to different markets, and persistence is key — trying numerous markets might eventually yield a willing insurer.

Three Potential Paths Forward

Three potential scenarios are emerging that could shape the future landscape. These three options highlight the critical choices facing California's insurance industry as it seeks to adapt and evolve in response to ongoing challenges.

  • Admitted insurers, persuaded by recently enacted regulations, could return to the market and grow their presence in higher risk communities. In tandem, E&S insurers will continue see significant growth. While traditional players may look to return, they'll still likely take a conservative approach with gaps best served by the E&S market.
  • The industry might continue its current trajectory of restriction and tightening. This "business as usual" approach would mean stricter underwriting guidelines and limited coverage options, leaving the market in a challenging state. If rebuilding efforts don't incorporate new strategies, the cycle of risk and loss could simply repeat itself.
  • New entrants could disrupt the market by leveraging advanced modeling and technology. These innovators are exploring risk mitigation actions that could pave a new path, offering more tailored and proactive solutions.

Take Action to Improve Insurability

By taking the following steps, homeowners can significantly enhance their chances of protecting people and property.

Keep the Lines of Communication Open

Building strong relationships with both insurance providers and wholesalers improves homeowners' chances of securing coverage in a competitive market. Wholesalers, with their access to markets willing to take on higher risk accounts, can help identify overlooked opportunities. As the industry adapts to wildfire risks and regulatory changes, these connections offer a strategic advantage in obtaining necessary protection.

Aim for Innovation

Innovative strategies and forward-looking risk models can help ensure coverage remains available and affordable. Individual and community-level risk mitigation measures are essential in reducing potential losses, enhancing resilience and safeguarding the future of vulnerable communities.

Be Proactive

By addressing potential vulnerabilities — by implementing fire-resistant upgrades and maintaining defensible space, for example — homeowners can demonstrate their commitment to risk mitigation, making them more attractive candidates for coverage.

Contributor Information